See how our top-rated home insurance providers compare based on key metrics to help you decide which company is the right fit for you. Our team also suggests considering each company’s reputation and coverage offerings in addition to cost when making a decision.
Top 7 Homeowners Insurance Providers
According to our analysis using our in-depth methodology, the following are the best homeowners insurance companies:
- Allstate: Our overall top pick
- Nationwide: Our pick for inclusive standard coverage
- Farmers: Our pick for customizable coverage
- USAA: Our pick for military members
- Erie: Our pick for best service
- Liberty Mutual: Our pick for discounts
- Liberty Mutual: Our pick for discounts
*A.M. Best ratings accurate as of July 2024
Things to Know Before You Shop
Learn what to look for when shopping for home insurance to create a baseline of knowledge for comparing our top providers below.
How To Choose the Best Homeowners Insurance Company
Homeowners insurance can feel overwhelming to the uninitiated, but it’s not difficult to find a great policy once you understand the basics. Here are three important aspects to remember as you compare providers:
Cost and Discounts
Your cost for home insurance is dependent on factors such as your location, square footage and condition of your home, claims history, credit history and more. One way to reduce your premiums is to look for bundling discounts or savings for installing safety devices, paying annually and more.
Coverage Options
Besides standard coverage for your dwelling, other structures, personal property, liability and medical payments, most insurers offer additional coverage for a fee. These add-ons, or endorsements, include coverage for water backup, equipment breakdown, service line repair, identity theft, valuable personal property and more.
Claims Process
Hopefully, you never need to file a home insurance claim, but if you do, you want the process to go quickly and smoothly without adding stress to your situation. In addition to asking company representatives about their claim turnaround times and communication channels for initiating claims, find out if the provider was scored in the 2024 J.D. Power Claims Satisfaction Survey. This annual study measures overall customer satisfaction with homeowner insurance property claims on a scale of 0 to 1,000. Satisfaction is based on settlement, claim servicing, first notification of loss, estimation process and repair process.
Homeowners Insurance For Common Scenarios
The cost of homeowners insurance coverage will vary based on your specific needs, with your property, belongings, location and even credit history playing a role. We spoke with Kate Terry, the CEO of Surround Insurance, to learn more about how to find the right coverage across several circumstances:
Home Insurance for First-Time Homebuyers
For first-time homebuyers, it is important to take the time to understand home insurance fundamentals, terminology and coverage options. Look for providers that explain the basics, whether with informational content online or by speaking with an agent.
“If you don’t know what you’re buying, find a knowledgeable independent agent who can walk you through the process,” said Terry. Some providers also provide online tools to help policyholders create home inventories, estimate replacement value, understand local risks and more.
Insuring a Home in a High-Risk Area
Homeowners insurance will likely cost more in areas considered high-risk, including living in an area prone to natural disasters such as tornadoes, hurricanes or earthquakes, or a higher-crime area with elevated theft risk. You may need to purchase separate coverage for windstorms or hurricanes if you live in a coastal area. Having a newer roof can help keep your rates lower or improve your home’s chances of insurability.
“In a high-risk area, homeowners insurance may be difficult to find, or you may need both a policy from a state plan and a private insurance policy to give you more coverage,” said Terry. “Don’t leave shopping to the last minute — this can take some time to sort out.” If you get denied coverage by private insurers, you can look into your state’s Fair Access to Insurance Requirements (FAIR) plan, which subsidizes high-risk insurance.
To get a better idea of the best home insurance companies in your specific area, check out our state and city lists using the tool below.
Homeowners Insurance With a Dog
Standard policies typically cover damage caused by some dogs, but other insurers may exclude specific pets with a history of biting or even exclude entire breeds. Terry notes that honesty is the best policy, offering homeowners the following advice: “Be upfront with your agent about what kind and how many dogs you have so they can match you to a company that will insure you. This way, if your dog does bite, the insurance company doesn’t refuse to pay the claim.”
Providers that institute a banned breed list may refuse coverage for certain breeds perceived as aggressive, such as pit bulls and rottweilers. If this can affect your application, consider finding an insurer that does not ban animals or working with an agent to find a policy that meets your pet-related needs.
Insuring Valuable Items
Homeowners insurance also covers your personal belongings damaged by named perils such as fire, windstorms, theft and vandalism. But policies often enforce sub-limits of $1,500 to $5,000 on valuable items, such as jewelry, furs and original art. You may consider purchasing an endorsement for scheduled personal property if the value of your luxury items exceeds your policy’s coverage limit. Scheduled items are covered for the appraised value if damaged by perils not included in standard coverage, such as accidental loss.
“There are also stand-alone policies for very high-value collections, like fine art or wine,” said Terry. “The same agent who you use for homeowners will typically have access to these.”
Home Insurance for an Older Home
Older homes built with outdated materials are riskier to insure because they may require more extensive plumbing, electrical or roofing repairs, or feature historical architecture that is difficult or expensive to replace. If you’re having trouble finding affordable coverage for an older home, consider updating the aging components of your home with modern materials and techniques. You can also look into local building codes to bring your home up to current standards.
Terry offers the following advice if you need help: “An insurance agent in your area will know which companies will accept your home in the first place, and are less likely to cancel your policy after an inspection.”
Switching Home Insurance Companies
If you already have home insurance, you do not have to stick with your provider for life — you can switch insurers if you’re unsatisfied with your current policy for any reason. However, you’ll want to consider if the pros of changing companies outweigh the cons. For example, you could face penalties for terminating your coverage early, so you may find it more cost-effective to wait until your current policy’s renewal date before you move forward with switching providers.
Once you’re ready to make the switch, it’s best practice to compare home insurance rates from several companies to ensure you’re receiving the coverage you need at a price that fits your budget. In addition, comparing your current policy to a new policy could help you identify any gaps in coverage. If you’d prefer assistance during this transition process, working with a licensed insurance agent may help alleviate your worries and ensure you find the right plan.
“The biggest thing to watch out for is whether your new insurance carrier is going to do an inspection,” said Terry. “If [a company] does [an inspection] and finds anything [deemed] not acceptable — such as a loose shingle or an overhanging tree limb — it may give you a relatively short period of time, like 30 days, to fix the problem or it will cancel your policy.”
How Much Homeowners Insurance Do I Need?
Generally, you need enough homeowners insurance to rebuild your home completely in the event of total damage, factoring in inflation’s impact on replacement costs. Many home insurance providers have detailed forms asking for information about your home to calculate estimated replacement costs. The Insurance Information Institute (Triple-I) also has information to help determine your home’s rebuilding cost and a home inventory guide to estimate the value of your belongings.
Here are some recommended coverage amounts to keep in mind when shopping for a home insurance policy:
Coverage Type | Recommended Coverage* |
Dwelling | Amount needed to replace or rebuild your home |
Other structures | 10% of your dwelling coverage |
Personal property | 50% of your dwelling coverage |
Loss of use | 10% of your dwelling coverage |
Liability | $300,000–$500,000 |
Medical payments | $1,000–$5,000 |
*We obtained recommended coverage amounts from the Triple-I and Policygenius.
Do I Need Home Insurance Endorsements?
Although your main policy will cover the basics, those who want extra coverage for things like natural disasters, high-value jewelry or even identity theft will have the option to select add-ons, or endorsements, when signing up for a policy. Endorsements are only required for certain natural disasters like hurricanes and flooding when the risk of an event is extremely high, but just because coverage is not required does not mean it is not beneficial. Use the map below to discover the top three home insurance threats in your state and decide whether or not purchasing extra coverage is the right decision for you.
Do I Need Homeowners Insurance?
State laws within the U.S. don’t typically require you to purchase homeowners insurance. However, if you currently have a mortgage on your home, your lender will likely require you to buy a policy, as the bank has a financial interest in your home if something goes wrong.
You could skip purchasing a homeowners policy if you own your house outright. However, remember that you will have to cover any damages in the event of a fire, theft or injury to another party on your property. If you don’t have the savings to pay out-of-pocket for potential damages in situations such as these, homeowners insurance can help protect you against any financial risks associated with home ownership.
Homeowner Trends in 2024
According to the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA), U.S. house prices rose 7% from February 2023 to February 2024, with Redfin putting the median U.S. home sale price at the end of April 2024 at over $383,000. Redfin also points out that new home listings are up 10.2% year over year and that its Homebuyer Demand Index — which measures the requests for tours and other services from Redfin agents — is near its highest level in eight months.
Zillow reports that almost 59% of U.S. homeowners own their home with a mortgage or a loan — meaning that around 30% of homeowners are mortgage-free. If you’re one of these homeowners with no mortgage, you may choose to go without homeowners insurance, as it’s not required if you don’t owe money to a lender. However, you’ll need to be ready to take on the costs associated with events such as fires, theft, accidents, and more occurring in your home and on your property.
If you’re a new homeowner in 2024, budgeting is likely something you’ve considered as you take on new bills and costs associated with homeownership. If you have a mortgage and are required to purchase a policy, finding the right insurance coverage doesn’t have to break the bank. Several of our top picks — such as State Farm, Erie, USAA and Allstate — made our list of cheapest homeowners insurance companies.
Frequently Asked Questions About Homeowners Insurance
Other Insurance Resources From MarketWatch Guides
Discover our top recommendations for the following insurance types to find the providers that best meet your needs.